Why not just go to the Kerths site, and start with those? They go back for several years - to 1998, i think and are a guide to what many people have enjoyed. As well, because of the diversity of the categories, you'll get a of range of story types. For example, if it's angsty relationship fics you like, you'll find a category for that.
That way we don't get into these lists that exclude so many writers and can be discouraging for those writers who are overlooked.
