Oh, how I wish my memory wasn't swiss cheese... because I know I was hooked to the show from the start and I'm mighty certain I was glued to my screen during the pilot, but I don't remember the moment that "made it" for me. (when we moved, I found my old VHS tapes that have every S1 ep, except the pilot, which can only mean one thing: I watched the pilot and recorded all the others so I could keep 'em.)
Most likely, it would have been seeing Clark standing in front of the mirror, in the Superman suit, taking off his glasses -- because when I got the DVDs and watched that scene, it was the one thing that made me go "omg, I so loved that show!"
