Here is my responce to the latest questions.
Then I will do my Recap
1) Would either #1, #4 or #9 be considered famous?
2) Would either #1, #4 or #9 be from my favorite seasons: season two or season three?
Q1 Famous in the LnC universe, hmmm...
#1 Only among those that are looking for place for a diner and a show.
#4 only to wharf rats and those that readers that are familiar with DC comics.
#9 only among the respectable throngs that read the Daily Planet.
Q2
#1 no
#4 Season 3
#9 no
If the remaining chaacters were all on a deserted island (Like on Lost), who would assume the role of leader?
If the remaining Characters were on a deserted island, who would be first eaten?
Q1 That would be tough and probably end up with a split group. In that case, #1 and #9 would be the leaders, with #4 possible being a runner up. #8 would try, but no one would actually follow him.
Q2 Sorry, this Game Master can't think that way. Besides, #'s 9 and 8 wouldn't let something like that happen.
Queen of the Capes snuck these in on me!
Has #1 Appeared in more than one episode?
Is #4 Batman?
Q1 No.
Q2 Batman is not in this series. However, #4 is famous in more than one Superman Universe.