Oh, I'm dangerous in a thread like this. There are so, so many that I read again and again. I have to ditto the "anything" recommendations for Kathy Brown, ML Thompson, Sue S., CC Aiken, Nan Smith, Wendy Richards, ShadowFax, David & Yvonne Connell (when I'm in the mood for angst).
I shall limit my Kathy Brown recommendations to
Camping with Clark (nFic available) and the "Momentum" series.
Check out Labrat's stories, my personal favorite is
Sugar and Spice Like a lot of others, I make my way through ML Thompson's stories at least semi-annually (if not every few months). I seriously cannot pick a favorite, but the most recent re-reads were
A Matter of Destiny (see also parts 2 & 3 in the series) and
Without a Superman (Clark Kent\'s Quest) (part 2 of 3 - Lois Lane's Quest - is my favorite part.
Single White Kryptonian and
Nocturne by Shayne Terry are wonderful.
Most stories by Meredith Knight. If you haven't read her stories, start with
A Closet Encounter and work your way through the rest.
I love
Anybody\'s Baby and
Tea Totaled by Annie M.
50 First Revelations by MetroRhodes and Sue S. is worth several read-throughs.
It\'s All About The Raisons by Gerry Anklewicz (see also Roadtrekking).
Cat Bruce has a lot of gems, but when I'm in the mood for crack!fic, I read
The Great Blankie Caper 
For a more subtle, yet hilarious story, I read Mary's
FoLCs In the Mist For WaFFs, one I read is Janet Owen's
Any Time at All I'm also partial to AU's - see below for some of my favorites:
Jeff Brogden's
Lost and Found .
Kaylle's
In Dreams (this story prompted my first feedback email when I became a FoLC)
The Long Road Home by Erin Klingler. See also
The Accidental Husband Tryst by Pam Jernigan
Meet Me in Kansas City by Chris Mulder
Raconteur's
Lifeflight Series.
