Hello Victoria,
I agree with both your positive and negative. I had actually considered both before I had even posted, but my interpretation of "Overall" is, I think, pretty much what you mean by "All-Round." To provide an analogy which anthropomorphizes the stories, it would be like choosing the best general contractor; they might not be the absolute best plumber, electrician, or carpenter, but they are the one person who is best able to handle all of the relevant construction tasks; if you could only hire one person to do an entire job that required these diverse skills, they are the one you would want to hire.
Joy,
Lynn
