Lois & Clark Forums
Posted By: Supes1fan FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 11:24 AM
Oh this is very bad for Cla- I mean Kal!! eek

Poor Lois..she's going to FLIP!

~Liz
Posted By: L Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 11:29 AM
Dead. Meat.

Delicious way to leave this off. But come back!!!
Posted By: TicAndToc Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 12:31 PM
Oooooh. Here it comes... <wince>

You guys sure are ones for cliff hangers, aren't you?

~Toc
Posted By: Laurach Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 12:59 PM
Oh my! The best part is coming, don't leave us hanging too long. Laura jump
Posted By: meclone2 Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 01:20 PM
Clark is so dead. smile1

And the best part is, I can't find it in me to pity him at all. He deserves everything that's coming. Of course, that's assuming that it was an unwitting revelation scene.

More soon please!
Hi,

Great part. thumbsup

Quote
And yet being in love with Kal felt like a betrayal of Clark. She couldn’t forget Clark. She couldn’t put out of her mind the way he’d smiled at her every morning when she walked down the ramp and into the bullpen, the way he’d brought her coffee without her having to even say she needed her caffeine fix...
mad Lois you should be ashamed of yourself.

wave
Posted By: Shadow Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 03:13 PM
I knew it! *evil dance*

He's so dead.

JD
Posted By: Julia Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 03:22 PM
Interesting! She's going to kill him wave
Posted By: SuperRoo Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 03:58 PM
YES!!!!!!!!! FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes I did yell that out loud.

This is the best.

Please don't leave us hanging.

*cough* *cough*

oh...poor....me. I have a cold.

Please pitty me and post soon.

*cough* *sniffle*
Posted By: Karla Kent Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 05:52 PM
OMG!!!!!

He is so dead...Lois will kill him with a laser of green kryptonite [Linked Image]

Come on!!!!!! For Luthor´s name Clarkkkkkkkkk just tell her the truth [Linked Image]

Please post the next part soooooooooooonnnnnnnn!!!!!!!!
Posted By: Tank Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 05:58 PM
In my opinion there is only one way that Lois could ever forgive Kal for his deception. Actually I don't really believe there is any way that Lois could forgive him, but for the sake of the story, if she could, it could only happen if Clark stays strong.

He can't go all wishy-washy and grovel. That would only validate Lois' feelings of betrayal. He has to stick to his guns as to the fact that 'Clark Kent' *is* dead. Even if the body didn't perish, the identity did. There was no good reason for him to tell her that Clark wasn't really killed, because for all intents and purposes, he was.

Of course, we all know that the logic is flawed, especially when it comes to sparing Lois some of her grief. But the only way she might forgive him is if he can convince her that his decisions were made under that convictions that her partner, the Daily Planet reporter, Clark Kent is now, and always will be, dead.

Tank (who doesn't believe that's what our two intrepid writers of story will do, but he is curious as to what they think might work)
Posted By: ethnica Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 06:18 PM
I know she can't hurt him, but gosharooney, I wish she could. evil
Posted By: Sheila Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 06:34 PM
YES! grovel
Posted By: Julie S Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 09:07 PM
Oh. Wow. Clark. Is. Dead.

But in any case, she finally knows. Now what's left to see is what will be left of his once she's done with him. goofy

I mean, I can see why she'd get even more provoked by the fact he put on his own shirt, assuming it'd be okay. Just strolling out of there like that. Looking, in a way, victorious, that he'd won Lois (by deceit), and he can just wear whatever he finds in her bathroom and no matter if it's Clark's shirt (which to her, is like a holy memory). I guess she might also think he recognized it since it was his, and put it on to symbolize that "Clark is dead; long live Superman." Only while he can say that to himself, Lois wouldn't be very happy with a statement like that.

Quote
And he was hers.

Well, mostly.
I could just hear the narrator say that. Starting with this wholesome voice of Happily Ever After, and finishing with a completely different tone of voice. Which I suppose is how Lois feels, and she can't let go of this other tone of voice.

Quote
There was no sense of loneliness, of insecurity.
Quote
She had to know what had dragged him out of her bed. Why he'd left her. Whether it had been an emergency, or... Or if he'd just changed his mind. If he'd decided he didn't want her after all.
No. No insecurities at all. Poor Lois. frown

Great part - now get on with it. We want to see if Clark can manage to stay in one piece. <g>

Julie smile
Posted By: Karla Kent Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 09:48 PM
More,more.more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more help

Pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeee hyper
Posted By: Karla Kent Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/06/04 09:48 PM
More,more.more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more,more help

Pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeee hyper wildguy wildguy wildguy
Posted By: SJH Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 05:24 AM
Damn that shirt!
Posted By: avia Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 06:12 AM
H and W,
I am now sure the only reason you’re collaborating on this is an attempt to reach the ultimate cliffhanger.

I’ve read all the comments people made before me and I just need to remind everyone of one very important fact – this is a story written by two evil writers trying to write the most angsty story ever. That said - having Lois realize now Clark didn’t really die protecting her seems a little too simple a solution. (I’ll stop at this point as this evil twosome doesn’t need any more encouragement or ideas.)

Looking forward to the next part,
Avia
Here lies Clark Kent AKA Superman
1966-1994
Torn into little pieces by irate former co-worker

"He should have listened when we told him to tell her."
Posted By: KathyM Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 09:21 AM
Well, if Lois doesn't kill him, then I will...

Wendy & Kae, as you know, I had problems with Clark sleeping with Lois as Superman, even under the extreme circumstances that they found themselves in. But I understand the premise for your story and I've been staying in for the ride.

And I read Clark's justifications, I see his despair when new circumstances crop up...but despite all, for me personally I just can't believe that he would actually do all this.

Having read *many* revelation stories, I sometimes get annoyed when Lois typically goes over the top and refuses to forgive Clark for a long period of time. Makes him grovel, etc. There are certainly elements there that are canonical, but this is probably why some people complain about the "doormat" aspect of their relationship.

But here, I'm not quite sure how she could ever forgive him. People make colossal mistakes, and can be forgiven. But he is piling on one after another, and has had several clear opportunities (that he's recognized himself) to pull back and just tell her.

I don't think I've ever rooted for Lois *against* Clark before. It'll be an interesting change...

Kathy
Posted By: daneel Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 09:22 AM
hyper
Posted By: dundan8 Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 09:42 AM
You're officially heading towards horror fic with L&C, congrats!
Posted By: Karen Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 10:19 AM
*thunk* Well, now *there's* a revelation.. what shall our dynamic duo do?

Ah, so many people think that Clark is dead. Can't they see that Lois will be soooo happy to have Clark back, that she'll collapse, sobbing on his chest, and forgive him anything and everything? confused

Yeah. I wouldn't believe it, either. *snicker*

Can't wait to read the rest of this.
Posted By: Sira Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 12:07 PM
*sings*
He is dead, so dead, so dead, so very very dead...
*end singing*

Well, but knowing this writing duo, Lois might just take it back and say, that 'Kal' in this shirt looked for a moment like Clark... And then we continue with Clark digging a hole for himself that's REAL deep.

On the other hand, this just might be 'the' revelation. And then, well, he's dead. More dead than he already is.

Sira - I want more! Please!!!!!

PS: It just cracks me up to read comments like:
Quote
Clark is dead.
Well, that happened in the first part, I believe... After all, that's what all this is about! LOL rotflol :p wink laugh rotflol
Sorry, I couldn't resist... blush
Posted By: Artemis Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 02:59 PM
Yep, he is so dead. But I bet he keeps digging his hole deeper and deeper. Ah, what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to deceive. And Clark is deceiving himself as well as Lois.
cool
Artemis whinging mecry wallbash
Posted By: SJH Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/07/04 08:36 PM
Lois give up all that good lovin'? I dont think so.
Both individuals are emotionally dense obviously, but neither wants intentional harm to the other.Deception may have been the result, but not Clark's intention. And intent has to stand for some thing.
What we have here is a lesson in gross time mismanagement: sooner or later your mistakes come back to bite you on the butt.Damn that shirt.
Posted By: Kaethel Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 11:41 AM
There seems to be a trend among you, beloved readers...

Quote
Oh this is very bad for Cla- I mean Kal!!
Quote
Dead. Meat.
Quote
Oooooh. Here it comes... <wince>
Quote
Clark is so dead.
Quote
He's so dead.
Quote
She's going to kill him
Quote
He is so dead...Lois will kill him with a laser of green kryptonite
Quote
Clark is so dead!!
Quote
Oh. Wow. Clark. Is. Dead.
Quote
Here lies Clark Kent AKA Superman
1966-1994
Torn into little pieces by irate former co-worker
Quote
*sings*
He is dead, so dead, so dead, so very very dead...
*end singing*
Quote
Yep, he is so dead.
goofy

Kathy, thanks for sticking with us even though you don't agree with Clark's behaviour. We have to reassure you and everybody else: neither do we. We both believe that Clark's actions are flawed and that he should indeed have told her. We also believe he made a big mistake by starting a relationship with her as Superman. But we think that from his point of view, there was nothing left for him to do as Clark. Clark Kent was well and truly dead, and his only chance at a relationship with Lois was as Superman. Yes, he was deceiving her, but was he truly aware of that? He was only Superman. Clark Kent didn't exist any more. Anyway, his reasoning is of course flawed - but we definitely believe he could have gone through that. smile

So... you all seemed to enjoy where we left it off. laugh Let's see if you enjoy the next section then. evil

Wendy and Kaethel smile
Posted By: L Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 11:47 AM
Believeability in the course of character actions is VERY important to me. I won't read stories where I don't feel that the behaviors make sense.

This being said, the behaviors up til now have made plenty of sense to me.

Do I think he was SMART? No. But he's reeling from pain - the pain of losing himself, of losing her (because he did - he lost the life with her he wanted...), and he's blinded by that, staggering through this crushing grief - as is she, for different reasons...

I believe everything up to this point could happen for these characters. But I also think - this is WAYYYY harder to get out of then the normal revelation where yes, she's mad, and blah blah blah, but honestly - he's an alien on a planet that doesn't exactly welcome "strange" and he had every reason to keep his identity secret. Is it his fault that he also happened to work with the woman who had such a huge crush on him? Is it his fault he fell in love with her?

So what I'm saying is - I like this and please more!
Posted By: Kaethel Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 11:50 AM
Quote
do I think he was SMART? No. But he's reeling from pain - the pain of losing himself, of losing her (because he did - he lost the life with her he wanted...), and he's blinded by that, staggering through this crushing grief, as is she, for different reasons...
Leela, what you're pointing out here is exactly what we were going for with this story. It's a huge compliment to us that it comes across to you the way we intended it to. Thanks!! smile

W & Kae smile
Posted By: Wendymr Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 12:06 PM
Absolutely! Leela, thank you very much indeed! You've seen exactly what we intend, and you're interpreting Clark just as we do here. smile

Anyway, I see Kae's posted part 8, so read on to see if Clark really does get torn into little strips of dead Kryptonian... wink


Wendy smile
Posted By: dundan8 Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 01:56 PM
Now with all due respect, I completely disagree.

No one has been able to explain WHY this is believable.

Yes, there is pain. This isn't a normal resolution.

Yes, there may even be trauma. This isn't a normal transfiguration.

Combine them and you still don't end up with this scenario because it's one word - SUPERFICIAL.

--

The more pain, the more trauma you add on top of it, the more it becomes hog-wash, really.

Not just in my opinion, because I have experienced severe pain in my life. I went through emotional agony where I almost died, and I thought I might even take my life. The support of my family has made me able to overcome that.

I was never in danger of taking my own life, but anyhow, as a result I went to a psychologist, several therapists. And yes, I still suffer from occasional trauma. What you two are describing here is not trauma.

In fact, people suffering from trauma have a hyperactive imagination and tend to relive the same events over and over again. Using trauma as an excuse for these two is almost insulting.

What I'm trying to say here is that I, perhaps in a less desirable fashion, understand pain on a much more directly applicative basis.

The only way Lois and Clark would behave in such a manner is if the only trauma caused to them was being hit over the head repeatedly with a baseball bat, after the said event.

That's pretty much the only scenario I can imagine where they would unfold in this fashion. I don't believe I'm being short sighted here, but I can thoroughly absorb their character without changing it. Because I don't apply myself. Period.

Lois and Clark is largely therapeutic for me. (I'm no longer the writer I used to be - I'm still recovering.)

Superficial is the word here.

--
Have you two ladies even researched what the effects of trauma are, beyond cases where the individual is clinically defined as unstable?

Again, this isn't a discussion on the fiction itself but on an issue that arises from the fiction. A mis-comprehension of human emotions.

I also know a lot more about psychology than your average person, so really, this kind of thing just doesn't fly, to me.
--
But I've probably said enough already. I don't want to sound mean, because I'm not. It's just a side issue that we end up treating problems so superficially only to convey our version of events. It just doesn't work that way.

We end up with emotional voids for these characters. Really, I gotta ask, where is the love. Because it's a contrast between fictional love and real love, that these (fictional) characters do (really) convey. I do believe this is just taking advantage of that and will in the long term just dry up the well of fiction-dom.

Then again, this is yet another TOGOM remake. What do I know. dizzy
Posted By: Wendymr Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 02:02 PM
Dundan, without trying to dismiss your experience and knowledge, I'd have to add that all individuals are different and react to events in different ways.

We know that you don't buy the events in this story as we're telling them. That's fine. You're entitled not to like the story or accept the characterisation. Equally, we're entitled, having read your posts and responded to them, to carry on writing the story as we wish if we don't agree with you. wink That's not saying that we don't respect your point of view; of course we respect it. But do you respect ours? :rolleyes:


Wendy smile
Posted By: dundan8 Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/09/04 10:07 PM
Quote
Originally posted by Wendymr:
Dundan, without trying to dismiss your experience and knowledge, I'd have to add that all individuals are different and react to events in different ways.
Yes, they quite do. I completely agree with that statement. Yada, yada, yada, we disagree on how the characters would react.

Again, that's fine. (Although that's a very ambiguous and generalised statement.)

Quote

We know that you don't buy the events in this story as we're telling them. That's fine. You're entitled not to like the story or accept the characterisation. Equally, we're entitled, having read your posts and responded to them, to carry on writing the story as we wish if we don't agree with you. wink That's not saying that we don't respect your point of view; of course we respect it. But do you respect ours? :rolleyes:


Wendy smile
I believe I have stated, my problem with this story isn't with the story, but with the superficial manner in dealing with its criteria.

Believe it or not, this is exactly the kind of story that touches on issues that go beyond any sort of genre that it relies on. Stories that deal with issues about drugs, etc. This IS one of them, although the subject is much more obscure.

This is sort of like attacking the mentally ill for one, and saying the events are fiction.

Who cares about the events? You're talking about things like MJ Thompson titled as, "Second Stages of Grief". Although I must admit I haven't read her story, this labels a clinical condition that doesn't exist as "normal". It isn't.

I wasn't necessarily referring to the events anymore, but to the causes that are so treated underneath.

Where's the respect in that?
--
Anyhow, if I have infringed any forum rule of etiquette I apologize for that, but it seemed to me like my point wasn't really clear.

I also believe that's not your point of view, with your focus being mainly on the story. I was merely suggesting that you pay more attention not on the action of the characters but on the subject matter being used.
Posted By: Anonymous Re: FDK ==> Whisper From The Dying - Pt 7 - 12/10/04 02:31 PM
This story is great, I like it lots, enough to stay late at work to catch up. Keep going ladies; there are those of us out here that are reading just for the enjoyment of reading without analyzing the hell out of it all.

TEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEJ
© Lois & Clark Fanfic Message Boards