Lois & Clark Fanfic Message Boards
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#290969 02/01/22 04:50 AM
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 2,513
Likes: 29
bakasi Online Content OP
Pulitzer
OP Online Content
Pulitzer
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 2,513
Likes: 29
Hey guys,

recently I encountered something that had me wonder - i.e. the use of the words affect and effect.

Let me give an example:

"Kryptonite has a humiliating effect on Clark. "

Someone told me it should be "affect" instead of "effect".

As far as I know, affect means something like feeling.

For example:

"Whenever Clark met Lois, his affects were running high. There was love and passion, but sometimes rage and despair in equal proportions."

Until yesterday I thought that was the proper (and only possible) use of these two words. My dictionary tells me the same thing. In German, these words exist in the same manner, they're just spelled differently.

Since the person telling me that my sentence was wrong is a native speaker - unlike me - now I'm confused. I told the person why I thought I was using the word correctly, but the reply I got was - curious. Like it was possible to argue the point.

I don't mean to point any fingers, I'm honestly just curious about this. I've seen some texts using the word "affect" in places where I thought it should be "effect", like in the first sentence I mentioned. But those texts were mainly fanfic, so there is never a guarantee for proper spelling and grammar.

If I change the sentence a bit, using a verb instead of a noun, it would be:

"Clark is affected by kryptonite in a humiliating way."

I can see why it seems to make more sense using the word "affect" as a noun. But as far as I can tell, the meaning is different.

So, what is going on here?

a) Am I wrong?
b) am I right?
c) it is indeed possible to argue the point, but my dictionary is not complete and as a non-native speaker I just can't know that?

Any thoughts?








Last edited by bakasi; 02/01/22 04:51 AM.

It's never too dark to be cool. cool
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 911
Likes: 2
Features Writer
Offline
Features Writer
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 911
Likes: 2
Hi bakasi,

The confusion between affect and effect is not confined to non-native English speakers. I've seen it confused by native speakers.

I think it depends upon how the kryptonite manifested and who is describing it. If you were describing a physical manifestation other than Clark's mental state, effect is correct in the first sentence. I'm most familiar with affect as a noun in medicine, where Clark's mental state would be described as something like this:

Clark's reaction to red kryptonite was apathy with a flat affect.

If the use of the word "humiliating" was interpreted as describing an emotional response, your second version of that sentence would be less confusing and correct. I can see where either interpretation is possible. If Lois, for example, was describing Clark's reaction as falling on the floor and writhing in pain as humiliating, she's seeing an effect of the kryptonite on his body, not necessarily describing a feeling or mental state.

Generally speaking, affect is considered an action verb. Both affect and action start with A, so that's easy to remember. Effect is usually a noun, as in this pneumonic:

"If an event affects your life, you'll feel its effects."

But not always, as in the sentence I wrote above, affect can be a noun. And to be even more confusing, effect can be a verb.

That quote above is from Grammarly post, which has a longer explanation with other exceptions to the rule (scroll down for them) and can be found at Affect vs Effect .

Hope this helps.

Last edited by cuidadora; 02/01/22 10:42 AM. Reason: typo

Cuidadora

"Honey, we didn't care if you were a Russian or a Martian... You were ours... and we weren't giving you to anybody." ~ Martha in Strange Visitor

"A love that risks nothing is worth nothing." ~ Jonathan in Big Girls Don't Fly

Joined: Jan 2019
Posts: 323
Likes: 3
B
Beat Reporter
Offline
Beat Reporter
B
Joined: Jan 2019
Posts: 323
Likes: 3
Interesting question. Like bakasi, I would also have gone with effect as a noun, and affect as a verb, but as we all know, language does not always need to be logical and/or make sense, and if something is used often enough by people, it sometimes becomes an accepted linguistic norm.


Up, up and away - to the next fanfic.
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 2,513
Likes: 29
bakasi Online Content OP
Pulitzer
OP Online Content
Pulitzer
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 2,513
Likes: 29
Thanks cuidadora. The grammerly explanation really helped to clarify this for me. So my perception of the word use was right. Perhaps, it helps that in my mind they are pronounced differently. Maybe that's because I started learning the British pronounciation. Or there are some perks to having sis verry evil german accent. grin


It's never too dark to be cool. cool
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 3,145
Likes: 3
T
Pulitzer
Offline
Pulitzer
T
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 3,145
Likes: 3
The article also mentions that each one can be legitimately used as either a noun or a verb.

Quote
Now that you’ve mastered the basic difference—effect as a noun and affect as a verb—it’s time to shake things up. In some contexts, effect is a verb and affect is a noun. Thanks a lot, English.
Remember, we're dealing with a language where "fat chance" and "slim chance" mean essentially the same thing.

I feel a headache coming on. That can be the effect (see what I did there?) of discussions such as these.



Life isn't a support system for writing. It's the other way around.

- Stephen King, from On Writing
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,977
Likes: 11
Pulitzer
Offline
Pulitzer
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,977
Likes: 11
Hi Bakasi!

Usually, "Affect" is the verb, and "Effect" is the noun.

"Kryptonite affects Clark. Its effects on him are nasty."

Rarely, you can use "effect" as a verb meaning roughly "to cause or create", and "affect" can be a noun in psychology, referring to the way someone speaks or behaves.

"Red Kryptonite effects a change in Clark's personality. Clark spoke with a flat affect when exposed to it."

Last edited by Queen of the Capes; 02/01/22 08:16 PM.

~•~

Moderated by  bakasi, JadedEvie, Toomi8 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5