I don't know if this is what you're looking for, but it sounds like my first fanfic (written when I was in high school) called "Better Family Hour" and I rewrote a few years ago and named "
Trials of the Heart ". Sorry if it isn't the one you're looking for. It isn't a great story, and I am still not proud of it, so it's probably not the story you're looking for.
- Laura