Lois & Clark Forums
Posted By: gr8shadesofElvis Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 08:40 AM
Made you look Beth! laugh (Yes, I am still a slow reader!)

Just had to start the thread quickly before I get thrown out of the library. Will read and review it at home.
Posted By: Beth S. Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 08:47 AM
rotflol
Posted By: carolm Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 09:25 AM
OOooooo yay!!!!

Yes, CK is much nicer in his jeans and T even at... 50?

Kaylie with powers?!?! eek eek eek

I know she's doing it for all the right reasons and it may even help her investigation but... wink

I love that they're over their fight and that all the superheros are NIA agents!

Evil NIA guy needs to go. Leave my Supernova alone! [okay okay, Kaylie's Supernova wink ]

No I didn't recognize the doc from earlier.... no points for me frown .

More. Now. Need a beta?!?!
Carol
Posted By: Laurach Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 10:22 AM
Wow this just gets better and better. More soon. Laura
Posted By: gr8shadesofElvis Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 11:15 AM
(Good news, I wasn't evicted - I left quietly and of my own accord.)

So how many points do I get for remembering Brad (or was it Mike)? He's bigamous Lucy’s husbands! goofy

But hang on now, Sven's flaky wife works at STAR labs? She's the coffee girl, right?

And eek , anyone for superpowers? Me! Me!! hyper

A real blast from the past, so to speak. But will it work? And is she going to go out and play with her new-found ‘toys’? That will be fun, seeing her learning to use her powers.

Or is it all just a cruel hoax?

Next week’s Honesty: Kaylie was dead. There would be no parts 15-18. Beth was tired of writing. The End.

Nah! laugh
Posted By: Marcus Rowland Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 12:03 PM
This would be a BAD moment to find out that Kaylie is a sleeper agent programmed to steal superpowers for the NIA or Sproxton or something.
Posted By: carolm Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 12:44 PM
/me smells a TE
Posted By: Darth Michael Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 02:02 PM
Now we have Green-K, Red-K and Power-K laugh

Nice twist, bringing the Laser back. Not to mention the NIA recruiting Superman and family. And I'm sure it was totally selfless a motive cat

Michael
Posted By: Shadow Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 03:50 PM
Love it! Don't have time to write more now, but I can't wait to find out what happens next!

JD
Posted By: Beth S. Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 04:28 PM
Yay, FDK!

Carol:

Quote
Kaylie with powers?!?!
I know she's doing it for all the right reasons and it may even help her investigation but...
goofy I think maybe she might also be a little curious to see what it feels like. I know I would.

Quote
Wow this just gets better and better. More soon.
Thanks, Laura. The story is pretty much all written now, so I will probably start posting a little more frequently as I don't have to worry about hitting a busy spot and falling behind.

gr8shades, you are awarded 100 "Honesty" points in which you get to openly criticize up to five character names I've chosen (each name is worth 20 points). They never expire, so use them wisely.

Quote
Next week’s Honesty: Kaylie was dead. There would be no parts 15-18. Beth was tired of writing. The End.
Well, the original plan was for Kaylie to die at the end of this chapter and for Jon to go to Thea Whatshername for comfort. They of course fall in love, and get married within the month. But now that you went ahead and spoiled it for everyone, I'll have to come up with something different. Geez. wink

And um, about the inadvertent polygamy in the first chapter... I did originally plan to have the character's name be Mike, but then I remembered that Lois and Lucy already have an Uncle Mike which might cause for some strange conclusions to be drawn. But then I must've missed the second reference to his name when I changed it. Whoops. I think I quietly snuck back and changed the name in my original post, so now I can play dumb about that ever happening...

What bigamy? I don't know what you're talking about. mecry

JD, nice to know you're still reading. Thanks!
Posted By: Terry Leatherwood Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 04:36 PM
Beth, I think the best part of your response to the latest round of feedback was when you stated that you'd be posting more often.

You do realize that you're going to have to do it now that you've said it, don't you? Otherwise:

wildguy wildguy wildguy

Need I say more? I thought not.
Posted By: BJ Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 07:38 PM
Evil Agent Marcus said:
Quote
This would be a BAD moment to find out that Kaylie is a sleeper agent programmed to steal superpowers for the NIA or Sproxton or something.
I have just one thing to say to that - - "The Queen of Hearts".

laugh

BJ
Posted By: anonpip Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/22/08 08:29 PM
First off, Beth - extra thanks are ridiculous. You did all the hard work. I was just the lucky person who got to see how the story was coming sooner than everyone else.

And despite all the questions, I stand by your assessment of Lucy. (Given how I've written her in Ten Years, this probably isn't too surprising).

There is just so much I love about this chapter.

Quote
Unlike her father and brother, Ellie didn't wear glasses as part of her real world disguise. But the chaotic mass of golden hair that tumbled down her back was more than enough to distract any critical eyes. She was as bubbly as ever, which I knew from watching news clips was not the way she acted as Nebula. Nobody could ever confuse this vivacious woman with the serene superhero on TV wearing such a severe hairstyle.
For reasons I don't understand, Ellie, while minor, is one of my favorite characters in this story. I love this image of her.

Quote
He was absolutely enormous, taller and broader than Clark even, with a fuzz of white-blonde hair and deep blue eyes.
And I love the image this paints of Brad. The image I get of the current Star Labs with Ellie and Lucy next to this enormous Brad, makes me smile.
Posted By: carolm Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/23/08 08:06 AM
Quote
Originally posted by anonpip:


Quote
Unlike her father and brother, Ellie didn't wear glasses as part of her real world disguise. But the chaotic mass of golden hair that tumbled down her back was more than enough to distract any critical eyes. She was as bubbly as ever, which I knew from watching news clips was not the way she acted as Nebula. Nobody could ever confuse this vivacious woman with the serene superhero on TV wearing such a severe hairstyle.
For reasons I don't understand, Ellie, while minor, is one of my favorite characters in this story. I love this image of her.
/me jumps up and down clapping hands like a little child

/me can see it now: Honesty II: Ellie's Story

/me runs and hides
Posted By: dedecasale Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/23/08 09:20 AM
Quote
Quote
This would be a BAD moment to find out that Kaylie is a sleeper agent programmed to steal superpowers for the NIA or Sproxton or something.
Marcus, you've saved me! Now I finally know how to end this thing!
lmao… That is so not happening… It isn’t, right Beth?

Quote
I've talked to my BR extensively about Lucy's future, and we both decided that even though she was kinda ditzy in the show, she seemed to be the type of person who would grow out of that and end up doing something amazing.
That is right, I’ve always thought Lucy would mature with time, because she was supposed to be 18 years in the beginning of Lois & Clark, or twenty something. I like Lucy’s character so much I don’t know why they didn’t use much of her.

Quote
/me jumps up and down clapping hands like a little child

/me can see it now: Honesty II: Ellie's Story

/me runs and hides
smile1 Yeah, I’d read that! There should be more women heroes. In my head Ellie looks like Claire Bennet.

I’m not sure I like this part so much, there’s not enough of Kaylie & Jon. And Lois was there, but so distant. I like the part where she and Kaylie meet better. But I am anxious for next part. You can’t possibly think that you can get away with leaving me hanging at that moment?! I wanna know what happens NOW!!!
Posted By: Beth S. Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/23/08 02:09 PM
Terry, if you look close, you'll see that my exact words were that I'd probably start posting a little more frequently. I would say there's plenty of wiggle room in there. wink

And my first wildguy attack ever! Being chased by crazy spear-carrying graemlins was more exciting than I thought.

BJ, I'm not entirely sure I get your reference. Maybe I need to brush up on my Alice in Wonderland trivia...

Quote
For reasons I don't understand, Ellie, while minor, is one of my favorite characters in this story. I love this image of her.
This is probably because I really like Ellie too, which would show through in my writing. There are several things about her that I really identify with.

Quote
me can see it now: Honesty II: Ellie's Story
Um... I may or may not already have a partialy outlined idea for a story that might closely resemble something that could been regarded as a sequel to this story, using Jon and Kaylie as protagonists again. It is also just as probable that I have an idea of a story with Ellie as the protagonist that would take place after the previously mentioned sequel possibility.

Maybe.

Quote
I’m not sure I like this part so much, there’s not enough of Kaylie & Jon.
Yeah, I knew that some people wouldn't be too keen on this part cause of all the A plot stuff that doesn't really add too much to Jon and Kaylie's relationship. But I did have to get some things worked out as far as the A plot goes, and I do promise you that there will be more Jon and Kaylie one on one time in the near future.

Quote
In my head Ellie looks like Claire Bennet.
I could see that. The hair for sure!
Posted By: Terry Leatherwood Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/24/08 04:55 AM
Beth, you claimed:

Quote
Yeah, I knew that some people wouldn't be too keen on this part cause of all the A plot stuff that doesn't really add too much to Jon and Kaylie's relationship.
I don't understand how you can say that. Kaylie is about to make a great sacrifice for Jon. She'd demonstrating that she's willing to put her life on the line for him.

I know, you're thinking, "She's going to have super-powers! Where's the sacrifice?" But with those powers comes hearing people in trouble, seeing dangerous situations, knowing that she can help people and save lives and also knowing that she's not going to be able to do any of it! Ellie and Clark (and especially Jon) are going to try to make her sit in one place the whole time. She doesn't have the fine control she'd need to help effectively, so they're not going to want her to be out in public. Not to mention the fact that they don't want to have to explain having another super-powered woman flying around. (Ultra Woman redux, maybe?) And the psychological role reversal between Kaylie and Jon will have an impact on their relationship, one which we might not be able to predict.

Of course, those powers will come in handy when she confronts Sproxton. Boy will he be surprised!

I vote "YES" for the Ellie story! I think you could do so much with her, especially if she really gets to be friends with Kaylie.
Posted By: BJ Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/24/08 07:48 AM
Beth said...
Quote
BJ, I'm not entirely sure I get your reference. Maybe I need to brush up on my Alice in Wonderland trivia...
Erm, sorry about that. My reference to the Queen of Hearts was a feeble attempt at wit. When Marcus mentioned that Kaylie could be a 'sleeper agent programmed' to do some horrific thing, I immediately thought of the Manchurian Candidate (the 1962 film version with Frank Sinatra, Angela Lansbury, etc.). The mental program trigger phrase was to play a game of solitaire. The character went into a trance when he saw the Queen of Hearts. (although in the play, I think it was the Queen of Diamonds).

Beyond that, I'm really enjoying your story and can't wait to find out what happens next. It was fun and interesting seeing the whole family together and at ease with the doctor and Kaylie knowing who they all are.

BJ
Posted By: Beth S. Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/24/08 08:36 AM
Terry, I totally agree with what you said. What I was referring to in my comment was the long string of dialogue in which the characters uncover the meaning of project Titan. The whole Ultra-Kaylie thing doesn't happen until the very end, and so I was commenting that those not interested in A plot may not like the first 75% or so. But I'm glad that you do!

BJ, I've never seen the Manchurian Candidate, so that would explain why I didn't get the reference. wink
Posted By: ChiefPam Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/24/08 09:08 AM
I've read the story part and I've been reading the comments thread, and it's suddenly occurred to me that I haven't actually commented yet smile

Yes, lots of A-plot, but it's very logical (and the idea that someone can track super-people by using their auras is way creepy. In a good way.)

I hope to see some introspection from Jon and/or Kaylie in the next part -- there's all sorts of interesting issues to explore.

As always, eagerly awaiting the next post of Honesty...

PJ
who would recommend the Manchurian Candidate -- the good one, not the remake wink
Posted By: Beth S. Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/25/08 11:11 AM
Thanks for the feedback PJ! Good to know you're still reading. I'll probably post the next part over the weekend sometime.
Posted By: ChiefPam Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/27/08 02:18 PM
"Over the weekend sometime" she says... and yet, here it is, late Sunday afternoon...

PJ
Posted By: Darth Michael Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/27/08 02:54 PM
*Wonders if the server was not reachable constitutes a reasonable excuse. Like "the dog ate my homework"*

Oh, well, I'll leave the guy with the mask in his cave*) till tomorrow. Now that Kaylie is superpowered, the poor guy might get roasted otherwise smile I mean, I have seen what she did to Jon, and she loves that lunkhead.

Michael

*) not Batman
Posted By: Beth S. Re: Reviews: Honesty 14/18 - 01/27/08 03:25 PM
Umm... peep Sorry, guys. I had planned on posting another part sooner than this, but I use public internet, and I just couldn't drag myself out into the snow before now. And, boy was it cold!

The next part of Honesty will be posted...

Now!
© Lois & Clark Fanfic Message Boards