Lois & Clark Forums
Posted By: Queen of the Capes Asian Story Structure - 09/19/19 02:49 PM
Okay, so we all know about three-part structure: Rising Action, Climax, and Falling Action. It centers around the main conflict of the plot, and is simply How Stories Work. I found out recently that there is another way.

Kishotenketsu is a story structure that has nothing to do with conflict. (The story may or may not have some, this style doesn't care.) Instead, the plot is presented like this:

1. Ki (Introduction) - Elements of the story (setting, main characters) are introduced.

2. Sho (Development) - These elements are elaborated upon; we learn how characters interact and how everything fits together.

3. Ten (Twist or Surprise) - Suddenly, the story takes an unexpected turn. Maybe we cut away to a seemingly unrelated scene, or something happens out of the blue. It's an element of chaos for the narrative.

4. Ketsu (Resolution/Reconciliation) - The weirdness in the third part gets reconciled with the first two. We learn how the cutaway relates to the main plot, or how our characters deal with the sudden development. The story becomes a cohesive whole again.

An example from Wikipedia:
Quote
Introduction (ki): Daughters of Itoya, in the Honmachi of Osaka.
Development (sho): The elder daughter is sixteen and the younger one is fourteen.
Twist (ten): Throughout history, generals killed the enemy with bows and arrows.
Conclusion (ketsu): The daughters of Itoya kill with their eyes.

The first verse introduces the female characters of the story. The second verse gives more details about both. Verse three goes astray to an unrelated territory. Verse four explains: The main characters of the story seduce men with their eyes – killing them just as the, until now, unrelated generals who kill with bows and arrow – thus showing the relation of the daughters of Itoya and the killing generals.

As I said, I only recently discovered this, and others explain it better. Here's the Wikipedia Article, and a much better Introduction for Beginners. There's also this YouTube video of Eastern vs Western Story Telling which is how I learned about it in the first place.

Anyway, I think it would be neat to see some fics in this style. If you don't feel up to trying a full-length story with it (and who should blame you?) feel free to try a four-line poem like the one in the sample, just to get your feet wet and see how it feels.
Posted By: Terry Leatherwood Re: Asian Story Structure - 09/21/19 11:34 AM
(ki) I have been looking at some of the stories on the archive using the Random feature at the bottom of the splash page.

(sho) I have found some absolute gems there, some which are only cut glass, and some which are paste imitations (IMHO only).

(ten) I found this introduction to Eastern vs. Western storytelling fascinating, never having considered that one could tell an interesting story which lacked a central conflict.

(ketsu) I believe that some of the short stories which did not tickle my fancy can fit into this story form quite nicely, including some of the vignettes for which the authors apologized in advance for having no A-plot (central conflict).

Kishotenketsu is certainly different. I'm not sure the structure would support a long-form story whose target audience is steeped in Western-style storytelling, but it's still fun to expand one's knowledge and viewpoints. And I'm pretty confident that the authors who declined to include a central conflict were not consciously using this structure.

And I learned a new word. I have added it to my microscopic Japanese vocabulary. Konishi wa. (It's morning somewhere.)

Posted By: Lynn S. M. Re: Asian Story Structure - 09/22/19 09:55 PM
Hi Queenie,

What a fascinating story structure. It is indeed quite alien to me, but I'll have a go at it:

(ki) Clark Kent is Superman.
(sho) He is vulnerable only to kryptonite and magic.
(ten) Lois tried a new recipe.
(ketsu) Clark discovered a third weakness.

Joy,
Lynn
Posted By: Queen of the Capes Re: Asian Story Structure - 09/23/19 12:52 PM
OMG Lynn I love it! XD

Edit: Okay, I should probably put my own money where my mouth is, so here goes:

1. Lois Lane, ace reporter.
2. She has a knack for getting into trouble.
3. Superman stops a runaway train.
4. His heart stops when he realizes Lois is one of the passengers.
Posted By: Lynn S. M. Re: Asian Story Structure - 09/23/19 08:44 PM
Hi Queenie,

I like your story, too. Our stories feel like bookends to each other to me.

Joy,
Lynn
Posted By: Shallowford Re: Asian Story Structure - 10/07/19 05:00 AM
Originally Posted by Terry Leatherwood
Kishotenketsu is certainly different. I'm not sure the structure would support a long-form story whose target audience is steeped in Western-style storytelling, but it's still fun to expand one's knowledge and viewpoints.


There was something naggingly familiar about Kishotenketsu when I read the Queenie's post and it finally came to me. The writers of Boston Legal wrote court arguments for William Shatner's character, Denny Crane, using this form. During the ten, there was plenty of "Mr. Crane, please get to the point," but then the ketsu knocked the feet out from the opposition from a completely unexpected direction.

It worked and I think it was one of the best features of the show. It probably isn't long-form but the audience for courtroom drama television is about as Western as it gets. If Kishotenketsu could work in a formulaic lawyer show I think there are possibilities.

Posted By: coolgirl Re: Asian Story Structure - 12/12/19 03:53 PM
Originally Posted by Queen of the Capes
Kishotenketsu is a story structure that has nothing to do with conflict. (The story may or may not have some, this style doesn't care.) Instead, the plot is presented like this:

1. Ki (Introduction) - Elements of the story (setting, main characters) are introduced.

2. Sho (Development) - These elements are elaborated upon; we learn how characters interact and how everything fits together.

3. Ten (Twist or Surprise) - Suddenly, the story takes an unexpected turn. Maybe we cut away to a seemingly unrelated scene, or something happens out of the blue. It's an element of chaos for the narrative.

4. Ketsu (Resolution/Reconciliation) - The weirdness in the third part gets reconciled with the first two. We learn how the cutaway relates to the main plot, or how our characters deal with the sudden development. The story becomes a cohesive whole again.

Wow! That is a really awesome way to build a story structure. Makes me wonder if there's really science behind the art of story telling..
© Lois & Clark Fanfic Message Boards