So, I've been watching this, and I admit I'm slightly mixed in my opinions too. I'm hoping it improves, because I agree that it's got a bit of the super-friends vibe going and is a bit cheesy. But I love that Coulson's alive and there's been a few good laughs. I trust Whedon & Crew, of course, so I will obviously continue watching. Also, I love superheros, new tv shows, and the occasional bout of cheesiness. There really aren't too many mainstream/primetime superhero shows anymore (no, "Arrow" does not count) and I for one am intrigued by it and *fingers crossed* hope this starts a new trend....
In a lot of ways, it reminds me of ABC's last superhero tv attempt, "No Ordinary Family" that was on two, maybe three years ago. I really enjoyed that show, too, despite its cheesiness and several lacking points in the plot. "Agents of SHIELD" gives me the same feeling so far.
As a bit of a side note, I find that I have a bit of trouble understanding Fitz & Simmons. I'm usually really good at understanding accents, and I get most of the tech/"science" talk too, but they just talk so darn fast and it's making my brain go a little bit slower in processing it all.
Was awesome and completely unexpected! I hope we get a bunch of little cameos throughout the show (liked Robin's (Cobie Smulders) appearance as Maria Hill too).
All in all, I'll keep watching, hoping it's just in that early we're-still-getting-there phase and soon we'll get to the meat of it all.
(To be completely honest though, the number one new show to watch this season is by far "Blacklist." Please, please, PLEASE watch it, as NBC shows are always pulled off the air too soon and I want this one to make it!
)