Now we just have to find the perfect song. Any ideas?
I don't know if you saw the Julia Roberts's film
Sleeping with the Enemy (the plot of which would make a good thriller L&C fanfic and, now, that I think about it, I know I read one recently that was similar to that). Anyway, in it Julia's character catches her cute, drama teacher neighbor singing the Jet's fight song from West Side Story, while watering his lawn (I tried to find a clip of the scene, but failed). Something out-of-character like that would work.