Thanks for liking my idea and also for adding to it.
I can see this in two ways.
1. Negative: A story that has a lot happening in it will naturally end up in more categories, and so is obviously going to get more votes and therefore win. Is this fair to a story that was in a size category, but was neither a comedy, a revelation nor had a first kiss in it?
2. Positive: A story in lots of categories actually signifies that it caters to all audiences and genres. If it gets more votes then that is a clear indication that it is an 'all-round' story. Possibly that would mean that this category could be Best
All-Round Story rather than Best
Overall Story. In this case it could possibly be a voted category again (but still may lend itself to being a copy of the long category)
Being a mathematician I'm very much into statistics and comparing like against like correctly. Please accept my apologies for fussing over this.
Plus I still miss some of the older categories