Loved it! This completely makes sense! If anyone should recognize a disguise, it's a guy who disguises people for a living. He doesn't know Clark, he only knows Superman, so the first thing he would see is Superman in disguise. And he doesn't know about the clone gangsters running around town, so it's funny that he's still trying to figure out why they came to see him.
At first, I thought he was coming in to give me a "cease and desist" notice.
Bwaaa haaa haaa!!!
Take Barry, for instance. He looks a lot like Superman, but the moment he walks (much less talks), it's obvious he's not Big Blue.
Poor, sweet Dean Cain. Accents aren't his strong suit.
I've been writing about Barry for so long now, I can't think of him as anything but the Vatman clone.
Thanks for adding another story to the challenge!