I voted for Justin Whalen as the best Jimmy Olsen. It's really a tossup for second and third place for me, but I ended up giving Jack Larson second place and Michael Landes third place. To be fair, though, Jack Larson had more time to create a memorable Jimmy than Michael Landes did.
I've only read a small number of comics, so I'm not really the best judge for who came closest to the Jimmy Olsen of the comics. Except for Tommy Bond, I thought they all fit what I saw of the character in the comics fairly well. I ended up saying Justin Whalen and Michael Landes, though.
