Not to take the opposing view since I agree that you should vote for the story you enjoyed the most.
But that is not to say that the technical merits of the writing and the storytelling aren't a factor in that process.
I would think that if you liked the lyrical quality of the writing, the vivid imagery, or the clever use of dialog. They would add to that enjoyment of the story. It's not only about compelling A plots, or a thrilling B plot. It's also how those things are presented which encompass the whole.
So, basically, the totality of the story is what is going to give you your reaction to it. And you will have to judge on how you felt at the end of the story.
Bottom line, is your gut reaction.
Tank (who thinks that the vast majority of the writers of L&C fanfiction are a lot better than amatuers have any right to be)
